1. Introduction
In container shipping, carriers frequently seek to recover demurrage and detention charges from parties other than their direct contractual counterparty. This issue has become increasingly relevant due to rising charges and financial pressure on freight rates. Understanding who may be held liable for such costs is therefore essential for parties involved in the carriage of goods by sea.
2. Legal Framework
Bills of lading commonly contain a broadly drafted Merchant Clause. Such a clause typically defines the “Merchant” to include the Shipper, the Consignee, the holder of the Bill of Lading, the receiver of the goods, and any person owning, entitled to, or claiming possession of the goods or the Bill of Lading, as well as anyone acting on their behalf.
Carriers regularly rely on this clause when seeking to recover costs associated with the carriage. These costs are usually expressly referred to in the Bill of Lading and almost invariably include freight, container demurrage and detention charges, as well as collection costs.
Demurrage arises where a container, after discharge from the vessel, is not collected within the agreed free time. Detention arises where a container that has been collected and removed from the terminal is not returned within the agreed period. Bills of lading generally provide that, after expiry of the free time, demurrage and detention charges accrue on a daily basis and are payable by the Merchant in accordance with the applicable tariff.
3. Case Law
In practice, demurrage charges may escalate rapidly due to the high daily rates applied by carriers. The primary party liable under the contract of carriage is usually the Shipper, as the carrier’s contractual counterparty. Where the Shipper has become insolvent or cannot be traced, carriers often seek recourse against another party qualifying as a Merchant under the Merchant Clause.
The Consignee is commonly the first alternative target. Under Dutch law, the mere designation of a party as Consignee in the Bill of Lading does not render that party a contractual party to the contract of carriage. However, the Consignee becomes a party to the contract upon presentation of the Bill of Lading to the carrier. By such accession, the Consignee is in principle bound by the contractual terms governing the carriage, including provisions relating to demurrage. The same applies to a third-party holder of the Bill of Lading who is neither Shipper nor Consignee. Upon presentation, that holder equally accedes to the contract of carriage and may, in principle, be held liable for demurrage charges.
Other parties mentioned in the Merchant Clause do not, as a rule, become parties to the contract of carriage. A contractual definition of “Merchant” agreed between Shipper and carrier is insufficient, in itself, to bind non-contracting third parties. This reflects the fundamental principle of Dutch contract law that contractual obligations are voluntarily assumed and generally operate only between the parties to the contract.
In limited circumstances, the doctrine of negotiorum gestio may potentially provide a basis for recovery against the owner of the goods. Other categories of persons included in the Merchant Clause will, however, generally fall outside the carrier’s reach.
A noteworthy decision was rendered on 19 February 2020 by the Preliminary Relief Judge of the District Court of North Holland, location Haarlem (ECLI:NL:RBNHO:2020:1101). In that case, a party responsible for supplying and arranging the transport of containers, but not acting as carrier under non-negotiable waybills, sought to recover demurrage from the Consignee.
The court held that liability could be established based on the parties’ correspondence, arrival notices identifying the Consignee as “demurrage payer”, and invoices that had not been disputed and were partly paid. The court emphasised that liability did not arise solely from the Consignee’s accession to the contract of carriage, but from a separate contractual relationship inferred from the parties’ conduct.
4. Practical Implications
Carriers cannot rely solely on a broadly worded Merchant Clause to recover demurrage and detention charges. Liability primarily rests with parties that are, or have become, contractual parties to the contract of carriage. Consignees and third-party Bill of Lading holders should be aware that presenting the Bill of Lading may expose them to such claims.
At the same time, mere involvement with the goods or their ownership will not automatically result in liability. Clear contractual arrangements and consistent documentation are therefore crucial. Parties should closely monitor arrival notices, invoices and correspondence to avoid unintended acceptance of liability.
5. Closing Remarks
The recovery of demurrage costs remains a legally sensitive issue in container shipping. While carriers may continue to seek ways to recover their charges, contractual boundaries remain decisive. Recent case law confirms that liability may also arise outside the strict confines of the contract of carriage. Careful legal and commercial diligence is therefore indispensable for all parties involved.
Author: Daan Komen
HerikLegal advises, inter alia, on maritime, transport, insurance, and (international) trade law matters. This publication is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.